on this article:
Click here to read them or to add your own.
I am a novice to the growing of palms and a newcomer
to your publication and have become interested in growing some palms
(space permitting) as part of a personal interest in exotic looking
plants for indoors and out. I have a handful of questions, which
would be of help to me and may be of general interest to some other
of your similarly less knowledgeable readership:
1.1 have a few of the more obvious palms (Trachy's,
Chamaerops. Phoenix, Washingtonia) which I am growing either outdoors
or in a conservatory along with a mixture of various other "exotic"
plants. Despite the effect on appearance, I am always reluctant
to chop off browning leaves on any of my plants and would rather
they dropped naturally. I have a vague notion that as long as the
leaves show signs of greenness they will photosynthesise and help
the growth rate of the plants. With palms, though, my approach causes
problems because of the unsightliness of browning leaves, which
stick to the plants for ages. When can the leaves be removed without
any detriment to the plant?
2. I have tried some palms from seed this year:
Livistona chinensis and Jubaea chilensis. One of the latter germinated
(out of about six seeds) but none of the former. They were sown
in January in a peat-based compost, in a propagator (temp c.75°F)
put in a sheltered part of my conservatory. Now, I am not noted
for my patience, but still I am prepared to sit it out, but have
I much chance with the remaining unsprouted seeds and, if I went
wrong, where did I?
3. My Phoenix canariensis is outdoors flat bang
in the middle of my lawn in a sunny and reasonably sheltered position.
I would be deliriously happy if it were still there in years to
come and dream, one day, of hanging a hammock between this and my
Trachy. I know it will take some frost and cold once established.
Do I have to rush out before every cold spell to cover it with some
4. I will be going to Barcelona in a few months
and wonder if there are any places in particular you would recommend
for viewing palms and other exotica aside from Las Ramblas!
Chris Miller, London SE26
I'll try and answer your questions Chris.
1. On the subject of trimming dead leaves, you
have to strike a balance between leaving leaves on as long as possible
(green leaves are working leaves) and the appearance of the plant,
but I don't really think that cutting the leaves too soon can make
so much difference to the well-being of the plant.
2. Both Jubaea and Livistona seeds need to be
fresh to germinate. If they are, they usually come through in about
6-8 weeks, I don't think there's any hope after 6 months. Make sure
your compost is not too wet. Try using coco-peat, and U' you can
squeeze only one drop of water out of a fistful, then the moisture
level is about right. Palm seeds don't need light to germinate and
not all require high temperatures: Trachycarpus. Jubaea, Butia and
others do best without extra heat. More tropical species prefer
temperatures up to 80 or 909F. Mix the seeds (soak them for a few
days first, changing the water a couple of times a day) with the
coco peat in a clear plastic bag, then seal and label it. You'll
be able to see through the plastic when the first sprouts appear.
Both Phoenix dactylifera and P. canariensis are very easy, as it
Washingtonia, and Chamaerops. Butia and Brahea are much more difficult
and slow, sometimes taking a year or more to sprout.
3. Phoenix canariensis is quite hardy, and will
be O.K. during an average London winter. However, as you know, every
10 years or so we have a bitter winter during which your plant will
need some protection. Hessian, or an old blanket, is much better
than bubble plastic, which creates condensation and damp.
If it's desperately cold, you might consider
wrapping soil-warming cables around the wrapped plant. But that
would only be for a few days at most, and well worth the effort.
The best advice is: be prepared!!
4. You should visit the botanic garden at the
bottom end of Las Ramblas in Barcelona. There are not so many palms
there, but they are well worth seeing, as are the flocks of parrots
that are now wild in the area, whose forbears escaped from the tiny
and cruel cages of the Ramblas bird market. They look so much better
flying overhead than cooped up in captivity. M.G.
I am writing to you about a problem I have experienced
with Chamaerops humilis. I'm pretty sure, it's some form of disease,
rather like rust on roses. It now seems to have affected both of
my Chamaerops and although it responds well to treatment with Benlate
and doesn't seem to affect the overall vigour of the plants, it
does make them rather unsightly.
The symptoms are characteristic rust coloured marks
appearing mainly on the leaves but occasionally on the petioles.
In some bad cases, entire leaflets have turned brown, though this
is rare. It also seems to be restricted to Chamaerops, as I have
a Trachycarpus, a Phoenix and a Brahea nearby which seem to be unaffected.
Craig Snell, Highworth, Wilts
I am very familiar with these symptoms, but don't
know the cause, though if they respond to Benlate it's likely to
be some form of fungus. Can anyone else throw any light on this?
I have recently bought a 6' Neodypsis decaryi (Triangle
palm), which is in pristine condition, and is growing in my conservatory.
The temperatures are fine at the moment, but my fear is that come
the autumn/winter a minimum, almost constant temperature of 12°C/54°F
may not be sufficient. I would like to know just how tolerant of
low temperatures this species is, what are its needs, do you have
any accurate guidelines, and would it be best to keep it the warmer
living room in the winter?
John Woodhead, Whitby, N. Yorks.
The Triangle palm is a wonderful, exotic looking
palm that is very easy to care for. It needs warmth (but not heat)
to grow well during the summer, and is tolerant of cool temperatures
during the winter but only if it is kept on the dry side, and this
includes the surrounding air. So, if your conservatory is cold and
damp during the winter, bring it inside. However, U' the air is
dry (which it probably is if heated with an electric heater, or
by radiators) leave it there. Ease up on the watering, and keep
the soil barely moist. Neodypsis are incredibly drought tolerant,
but seem to be sensitive to over-fertilizing, so feed at half strength,
and only when it is in active growth. It should last forever! M.G.
Phoenix In London
While driving through London last autumn I was surprised
to see, growing on a traffic island, one of my favourite palms,
Phoenix canariensis. To me it's a real palm, possessing all the
qualities a palm should have, instantly recognizable as such, and
giving its surroundings an exotic atmosphere.
It's one I've wanted in my garden but I've always
thought it a little too adventurous to chance, so my ten-year old
specimen was confined to its pot. Then driving through London this
summer, down Cheapside in the City and down Park Lane, what should
I see? I couldn't believe it: two magnificent specimens outside
the Royal Bank of Scotland in Cheapside, and 6 smaller ones planted
down the central reservation of Park Lane, and, yes, the one on
the traffic island on Lambeth Bridge had survived the winter and
So given the brilliant summer we re having I've
taken my prized ten-year old and given it its freedom and planted
it out, much to the astonishment of my neighbours. It's been in
the ground about six weeks and has produced three new leaves. I
will protect it during the winter with straw and sacking as we re
colder here than in central London. I'll also pray for global warming!
Ken White, Shenfield, Essex
We've had several other letters about the London
Phoenix palms and will try to fit some photos in next time. M.G.
(No comments yet. Be the first to add a comment to
22-04-21 - 17:32GMT
|| What's New?
|| New palm book
| Date: 24-05-2004
of Cultivated Palms
by Robert Lee Riffle, Paul Craft.
|| New: Issue 48
| Date: 24-05-2004
has been published in the Members Area.
|| Archive complete!
| Date: 03-12-2002
| All Chamaerops issues can now be found in the archive:
More than 350 articles are on-line!
|| Issues 13 to 16
| Date: 28-08-2002
| Chamaerops mags 13,
have been added to the members area. More than 250 articles are now online!
|| 42 as free pdf-file
| Date: 05-08-2002
Download! Chamaerops No. 42 can be downloaded for free to intruduce the new layout and size to
|| Issues 17 to 20
| Date: 23-07-2002
| Chamaerops mags 17,
have been added to the members area. Now 218 articles online!
|| Book List
| Date: 28-05-2001
a look at our brand new Book List edited by Carolyn Strudwick
|| New Book
| Date: 25-01-2001
by Mario Stähler
This german book tells you all about how to cultivate your palms in Central Europe. more...