Very common in the wild, inexplicably rare in cultivation.
Until we set our sights on it, that is. Now it's beginning to appear
all over the place.
Gibbons & Tobias
Chamaerops No.35/36, Summer-Autumn Special 1999
Left: Trachycarpus martianus fruits
Right: Trachycarpus martianus, Marsyandi valley, Nepal
If you would like to see Trachycarpus martianus in
the wild, a good place to begin looking is between the covers of
Odoardo Beccari's work on Asiatic palms in Annals of the Royal
Botanic Garden, Calcutta. Published posthumously in 1931,
it is still the most recent full taxonomic account of Trachycarpus,
and summarizes, in a very readable form, all that was known of the
genus at that time (also see Myron Kimnach, Principes
21(4):155-160). Despite the fact that it was written 80 years ago,
Beccari was such a scientist that the information contained in his
book is as relevant today as it was when it was published, and is
surprisingly accurate in almost every respect.
Under 'Habitat' in the section on Trachycarpus martianus
we read, ".....Rather frequent in the Khasia Hills, between
1000 to 1500m elevation, at Lonkerden and at Noughedem, at Moosmai
and Manloo; in the latter locality Sir Joseph Hooker wrote that
'it grows on the cliffs' and 'that it may be seen on looking over
the edge of the plateau, its long, curved trunk rising out of the
naked rocks, but its site is generally inaccessible'......"
Having seen Trachycarpus takil and T. nanus in their
natural habitat, our next step along the Trachycarpus trail had
to be towards T. martianus, familiar by name, often referred to
and in just about every book on palms, and yet extremely rare in
cultivation. It exists in small numbers at Huntington Botanical
Gardens in California, but is represented in Europe by a single
mature specimen in a private garden in the south of France. It seemed
time to bring this beautiful tree out of the shadows and into the
The Khasia Hills are in Meghalaya Province in remote
north-east India. The whole area is 'restricted' and a permit must
be obtained before one is allowed to visit. The main town, Shillong,
is reached by driving south from Gauhati. To get to Gauhati, we
flew from Calcutta on an Indian Airlines airbus. The flight is just
45 minutes, but the ensuing bus journey, though only a fraction
of the distance, takes many times longer. This climb up into the
hills was a continuous pattern of overtaking lorry after lorry after
lorry, all crawling uphill and all emitting great clouds of thick
and poisonous fumes. This pollution hangs heavy on the still air
in the otherwise beautiful countryside.
Pollution aside, Shillong itself is a most interesting
and attractive town. Once a 'hill station' during the British rule
in India, it was, and still is, a cool retreat from the heat of
the plains. At 1500 metres above sea level the weather in October
was extremely pleasant, warm but not hot, the nights comfortably
cool. There are many examples of colonial architecture in the town;
unfortunately, much of this architecture is not maintained and therefore
decaying. The Pinewood Hotel is a wonderful example. Like an old
aristocratic lady fallen on hard times, it presents a brave face
to the world, but time has moved on and passed it by. These days
air conditioning, television in every room, and mini-bars are more
important than ballrooms and verandahs and tiffin and punkah-wallahs.
However, in the nicely maintained grounds (lawns, flower beds and
huge Araucarias), we saw our first Trachycarpus martianus, two tall
and beautiful trees.
We were to see many more in the town, often outside
public buildings, such as one outside the extraordinary Roman Catholic
Cathedral, best described as art deco gone mad. Ward's Lake Garden
in the centre of town boasted another dozen. They really are beautiful
trees; visibly distinct from all other Trachycarpus, and yet the
relationship is clearly seen. T. martianus has a comparitively large
crown of regularly divided leaves with a strong, whitish bloom on
their lower sides. Most have naturally bare trunks, and the fibres
from the old leaf bases cover just a foot or two below the crown;
old leaves can be pulled off with a minimum of effort. This however
is not a reliable feature for identification since other Trachycarpus
species can also shed their fibres naturally, or indeed they may
be stripped. Also we came across one or two trees in the garden
which had fibres right down to the ground, so there is clearly some
What is a reliable identification characteristic,
however, is the fruit and seed which is the size and shape of a
coffee bean rather than kidney-shaped as in every other member of
the genus. All of the female trees we saw had clusters of bright
yellow fruit hanging down from within the crown. We estimated 6,000
seeds on the six infructescences of a single tree. It is a terrible
shame that there are so few young plants. All of these mature trees
have been producing seeds in these huge quantities for 50 years
or more, so that countless millions of seeds have all gone to waste.
Presumably, when these old trees die, there will be no more Trachycarpus
martianus in Shillong, and the town will be the poorer for it. Curiously,
even officers at the Forestry Department in the town were hardly
aware of its existence, even though there were a dozen or more scarcely
a minute from their office. They were totally unaware of its existence
in the wild.
Having inspected and admired every cultivated tree
we could find, we were naturally impatient to look for wild specimens.
We rented a car and driver and with 'Beccari' clutched firmly in
our hands we set off to follow his directions, written 80 years
previously. Heading south from Shillong, we soon cleared the town
and drove through an undulating landscape, densely forested with
Pinus khasia, gradually changing into a totally deforested hilly
plateau, some 1400m above sea leavel. Around 80km from Shillong
we reached the town of Cherrapunjee, one time record-holder as the
wettest place on earth, with an annual 12 metres of rain. There
was certainly no rain on the day that we were there, though, and
we had a clear, fabulous, and unexpected view of huge cliffs, disappearing
down into the valley below us. Not far from 'Cherra' near the village
of Mawsmai (Beccari's Moosmai) there were more such cliffs, which
apparently marked the southern edge of the plateau.
In contrast to the hilly plateau across which we had
been driving, which was mainly grassland with the occasional Pandanus
thicket left in ravines and depressions, the cliffs and lower slopes
were densely forested. Though we saw other palms there--at least
two species of Calamus, several Caryota - Fish Tail palms - and
a curious Arenga-like species we were not able to identify until
later--there were no Trachycarpus to be seen. Somewhat disappointed,
we decided at Manloo (today spelled Mawmloo) to drive further down
the road, which began to descend steeply in hairpin bends. From
the map we could tell that the road eventually ended up in Bangladesh,
which we could see, covered by lakes, in the blue and hazy distance.
As we went down, the temperature went up, and the vegetation became
more tropical. More palms began to appear, as well as bananas and
tree ferns. We again saw Caryota obtusa,with huge, flatly-held leaves,
and a little further down, at around 1000m a.s.l., a second tall,
slender Fish Tail palm. This one, probably Caryota maxima, had quite
different leaves in a tumbling habit, and was growing together with
great numbers of Calamus, later identified as C. erectus, in full
but unripe fruit. We were also very pleased to find Wallichia densiflora
which perhaps should have given us a clue as to the identity of
the mystery palm from before, which turned out to be no less than
Wallichia disticha, not previously recorded for the Khasia Hills,
with its unique, 2-ranked arrangement of leaves. Palm hunting has
to be done carefully here: huge yellow and black spiders as big
as your hand sit patiently in webs the size of dinner tables slung
between shrubs, waiting for the unwary to stumble in for lunch.
Lest we should end up, like the road, in Bangladesh,
we turned round in a tiny village and after having some 'chai' -
hot, sweet and milky tea served in a glass - set off back up to
Delighted with our findings but concerned about the
apparent absence of Trachycarpus martianus, we asked the driver
to take us to Nohkalikai Falls, just west of Mawmloo. We should
not have worried, for a few miles further on, looming out of the
mist that was now gathering as the day drew on, we saw them. First
one, then many. They were growing on the very edge of a precipice
that we could not see into because of the mist. We could hear the
distant roar of a waterfall, but frustratingly had to return the
following morning to see more.
The sun shone bright and clear as we drove back to
the same spot the next day. What we had been unable to see was now
revealed: the cliffs on the edge of which we were standing were
some 300m (1000 feet) almost straight down. The waterfall we had
heard was half-a-mile away at the head of the valley and the water
cascaded in free fall for many hundreds of feet, creating a rainbow
with the spray. We could look across the gorge to see the identical
cliffs on the far side, and huge butterflies were idly casting themselves
out into the void. It really was a magical place. At the base, where
the cliffs themselves moderate into a steep slope, densely forested
with small epiphyte-covered evergreen trees, we could spot Wallichia
disticha and that huge, broad leaved Caryota obtusa again, which
formed a conspicuous component of the forest canopy.
And then...we saw Trachycarpus! By the dozen and by
the hundred! They were growing, just as Sir Joseph Hooker had reported,
out of the bare rock, on ledges and in cracks on the south-facing
cliffs, absolutely inaccessible. Even a mountain goat would need
climbing gear. It occurred to us that we were undoubtedly standing
on the very spot where Sir Joseph had stood 80 years previously.
The rock itself was dark, soft and crumbly, and consisted of baked
quartzite sand. Combined with this was not limestone as we had expected:
the soil was sandy and strongly acidic with a pH of only 4-5.
The Trachycarpus were beautiful! The original trees
we had spotted from the car were much closer; indeed, by leaning
out slightly over the brink we could actually touch them, though
to collect seeds and herbarium specimens would have required some
ingenuity with poles and wire and secateurs, as well as a head for
Their trunks were growing straight out, or sometimes
curiously bent away from the cliffs. Although a few younger plants
had their trunks entirely covered, the coarse, loose, light brown
fibres of the leaf bases persisted only just below the crown in
adult trees, and under this a slender, smooth trunk was revealed
with clearly visible, closely-spaced leaf scars. The young petioles
and unexpanded leaves were covered in dense white tomentum. The
leaves themselves were large, appproximately 120cm across, medium
green in color above and strongly glaucous below. They were very
regularly split to about half way, into sometimes more than 75 stiff,
erect segments, shallowly bifid and acute at the tip, presenting
a distinctive, indeed unmistakeable, silhouette. A unique feature
of Trachycarpus martianus leaves is the small transverse cross-veins
which run from one longitudinal leaf vein to another. These cross
veins are much clearer than on other Trachycarpus species and are
apparent even on seedlings and 100-year old herbarium specimens.
Petioles as well as inflorescences (up to eight on a single tree)
were considerably shorter and more erect on these trees than on
the cultivated plants we had seen in Shillong and gave the palms
a much more compact and wind-resistant appearance.
Though Trachycarpus martianus seems doomed through
lack of interest in the town, its future in the wild seems as solid
as the rocks on which its grows. Because of the inaccessibility
of its habitat it is safe from those who would cut it down for firewood
or for building, and it is equally safe from goats, the scourge
of so many endangered palm species. Long may it remain so.
This article was first published in 1994 in Principes
Vol. 38, No. 2 and has been edited to fit the format of Chamaerops.
09-07-20 - 23:08GMT
|| What's New?
|| New palm book
| Date: 24-05-2004
of Cultivated Palms
by Robert Lee Riffle, Paul Craft.
|| New: Issue 48
| Date: 24-05-2004
has been published in the Members Area.
|| Archive complete!
| Date: 03-12-2002
| All Chamaerops issues can now be found in the archive:
More than 350 articles are on-line!
|| Issues 13 to 16
| Date: 28-08-2002
| Chamaerops mags 13,
have been added to the members area. More than 250 articles are now online!
|| 42 as free pdf-file
| Date: 05-08-2002
Download! Chamaerops No. 42 can be downloaded for free to intruduce the new layout and size to
|| Issues 17 to 20
| Date: 23-07-2002
| Chamaerops mags 17,
have been added to the members area. Now 218 articles online!
|| Book List
| Date: 28-05-2001
a look at our brand new Book List edited by Carolyn Strudwick
|| New Book
| Date: 25-01-2001
by Mario Stähler
This german book tells you all about how to cultivate your palms in Central Europe. more...