Interview with the Editor - Part 2
Second and final part of this no-holds barred,
unabridged and completely unexpurgated expose of your editor's Life-with-Palms
by Imtiaz McDoom-Gafoor, London, UK
Chamaerops No.38, Spring Edition 2000
Medemia argun, Nubian desert, Sudan
Imtiaz McDoom-Gafoor: Another palm recently available
is Trithrinax campestris. Where does it come from and what conditions
does it grow in?
Martin: Trithrinax campestris is an absolutely beautiful
palm, one of the most striking palms in the world Id say.
It has very stiff, very blue, fan shaped leaves and its trunk is
covered in an intricate network of old leaf bases and fibres and
spines - a very dramatic looking palm. It grows in the west of Argentina,
near a place called Corrientes. It grows in a band 50 miles long
and 20 miles wide and there are hundreds of thousands of trees in
this band. Large parts of this area are being cleared for the planting
of genetically modified foods like soya and sunflowers. The bulldozers
are sent in, destroying all these venerable old trees, often 100
years old, in an area of a couple of square miles at a time. They
are bulldozed into the middle of the field, poured diesel on and
set light to and the ashes ploughed into the ground. Sunflower and
soya seeds are then planted in their place. The bulldozers then
move on to the next area and repeat the same thing. I have a contact
there that gets in before the bulldozers and takes these Trithrinax
out of the ground and reroots them over several months and ships
them over to Europe. We had a container in the summer and they are
growing well in our back field. They are dramatic in appearance,
extremely wind resistant, surely one of the cold hardiest palms
in the world, and a stunning addition to an exotic garden.
IMG: What is the most memorable palm trip you have
Martin: It was rediscovering Medemia argun in the
Sudan. It was last recorded in Egypt in 1964 (a solitary tree, now
dead) and not recorded in Sudan since the 1920s or 30s.
We mounted an expedition to try to find it. It was said to grow
near a town called Murrat Wells, north of Khartoum. We arrived at
a city called Atbara on the River Nile and showed photographs of
Medemia argun but no one had heard of Murrat Wells until an old
camel driver was summoned. He said not only did he know Murrat Wells
but he also knew Medemia. Our excitement can only be imagined! After
a couple of days in the desert we came to Murrat Wells and it became
obvious why it was not on any modern map - it was a ghost town,
an old gold mining town deserted when the gold ran out. Beyond the
town the landscape changed and it became a long, low valley and
right at the end we could see something through the heat haze that
looked vaguely like a palm tree, maybe a Washingtonia or a Hyphaene.
As we got closer we realised it was Medemia argun, it was just so
We saw a number of trees, some of which were heavy with thousands
of big, plum sized, dark blue-black fruits. Two years later we returned
and found perhaps a thousand trees in several scattered populations.
Some were in good condition, others in very poor condition, and
it suggests that the underground water, which keeps them alive,
changed course over the years and deprived the palms of water and
hence their poor condition. However, there were many and they were
reproducing in the wild. I think their future is OK; they dont
really have any natural enemies, but there is a suggestion that
the whole area is much dryer than it was, so their long term security
is not known. We were able to distribute these seeds to most of
the botanical gardens in the world. It is the first time they have
been introduced into cultivation outside of the Sudan and many are
now growing around the world, wherever the habitat is suitable for
them. It was a very exciting trip and we had the added bonus of
being able to prove that this palm, which had previously been thought
to be extinct, was alive and well.
IMG: Why are so many potentially cold hardy palms
so poorly available in cultivation?
Martin: A lot of palms are obscure because they grow
in places that are difficult to access. Many grow on borders, like
Trachycarpus princeps in China, Burma, and Tibet. Likewise, Trachycarpus
takil grows on the border between India and Nepal. These border
areas are always very sensitive and both India and China are very
touchy about their borders, so there are always personal risks involved
in being in these areas. In addition to political problems, many
palms grow on cliff faces which are difficult to climb. The locals
may have cut down the more accessible palms, so getting to the remaining
ones is often a physical challenge. You have to sometimes row across
fast flowing rivers, climb up steep cliffs, and certainly climb
trees. One trip in South America we invested in a pair of tree spikes,
which are like spurs but with a spike on the inside and you strap
these to your legs. You literally climb up the trees, with a safety
harness, which would cushion you in the event of a fall. When the
palm is 40 ft tall and it is a Ceroxylon whose trunk is covered
in wax, its a hairy experience. Other times we have been stuck
in deep mud trying to cross the Andes. The higher you go the wetter
it is. The roads are unmade and muddy and you are miles from anywhere.
You have to make a decision: should we turn around or should we
go for it, and always it seems we went for it! Stuck in mud at night
at 3500m in the Andes, miles from civilisation, is not a lot of
fun, but all part of the experience. More than once weve had
to sleep in the car and go for help in the morning.
IMG: What is the most dangerous trip that you have
Martin: The most dangerous place we have ever been
to, and the country I was most glad to leave, was Colombia. We went
there not knowing how dangerous it was, and once there we met a
professor at the university in Bogota who was surprised that we
appeared to be naive enough not to know how dangerous it was. We
phoned up our respective embassies. I phoned up the British embassy
and they said that under no circumstances should we travel by road.
There have been several British nationals kidnapped already and
some of them are still in captivity. The embassy staff doesnt
travel by road unless it is absolutely necessary and then they go
with bulletproof vehicles and police escort front and back. Toby
phoned up the German embassy and was told a similar report: there
had been twelve German nationals kidnapped so far that year, and
kidnapping in Colombia is a huge business. And there we were in
our shiny, bright green, brand new, obviously hired car, saying
Tourists - come and get us! I was very nervous driving
around the countryside in Colombia. In fact, we had planned to spend
10 days there, and 10 days in Ecuador. We spent just 3 days in Colombia
and couldnt wait to leave. The extra 7 days we spent in Ecuador
and it was absolutely not wasted.
IMG: Which countries would you like to visit that
you have not previously been to?
Martin: I would like to go to Vietnam. North Vietnam
is worth visiting although there are probably a few unexploded mines
there which gives pause for thought. There has been very little
botanical exploration and many parts are still undiscovered from
a botanical viewpoint. I would also like to visit some other South
American countries. We briefly visited Brazil but it is a vast country.
I especially would like to see the temperate southern part, and
I would like to explore that properly from a palm point of view.
And of course, Burma, which I mentioned earlier.
IMG: You were involved in the formation of the
European Palm Society. When was it formed and how has it evolved?
Martin: It was formed about 9 years ago based on the
old Temperate Zone Chapter which was run by Tamar Myers in Ohio.
She ran the magazine for many years and I was just absolutely hooked
on it and used to read and devour and digest every word. It was
a shock when Tamar said she was to stop producing it. So three of
us got together, Tony King, John Churcher and myself, and decided
to start up the European Palm Society. At that stage we didnt
know what we would call the society or the magazine. We thought
of calling it Jubaea but then it seemed logical to name
it after a European palm and hence the name Chamaerops.
It now has nearly a thousand members.
IMG: How did the Palm Centre first begin?
Martin: The Palm Centre opened in 1989 after I started
selling duplicate palm seedlings. Eventually my entire house and
garden was filled with palms. I would have customers come round
at weekend and someone would ask for a palm and I would say, yes
I think there is one in the second bedroom or one on the first landing.
And so we would troop up the stairs and there would be another party
coming down. It got ridiculous! I started buying from Spain and
40ft lorries would be pulling up outside and blocking up all the
traffic. It was absurd and something had to be done. It took me
a year to find suitable premises and I eventually found a small
nursery, or shop and yard to be more accurate, in East Sheen, in
West London, not far from Kew Gardens. I remembered driving out
there for the first time and I thought that any minute I was going
to drive off the edge of the world. It just seemed so remote.
I had sleepless nights for about the only time in my life worrying
about the enormous expense of opening it. I would go to bed at 11
oclock or midnight and would wake up at 2 oclock in
a cold sweat thinking, oh God this is the most stupid thing I have
ever done, its never going to work, everyone is going to laugh
at me. But in fact it began well, and Ive never really looked
IMG: Where do you source the wide and varied palms
that you sell?
Martin: These days we get palms and other plants from
the four corners of the world. We get tree ferns from New Zealand
and Australia, big palms from Argentina in South America, from Costa
Rica in Central America, a lot from the United States and from several
countries in Europe, notably Spain but also Sicily. In fact, anywhere
where there are commercial nurseries set up for the export of palms.
Interestingly, I am always coming across new nurseries, new species
to try. The range of species seems to be increasing whereas you
would expect it to be finite.
IMG: The Palm Centre is now working closely with
a nursery in Spain to increase the availability of hardy palms in
Britain. Tell me about this venture.
Martin: It is so frustrating to go to some of the
best nurseries in the world, say in Florida or California and find
that they have just two or three plants of a rare hardy palm or
four or five or some that they dont want to sell. There is
no difficulty in growing these palms or getting hold of seed but
you ask yourself why arent they growing thousands of them
instead of only two or three plants? It cant be because there
is no demand. So a few years ago we started to supply large numbers
of seeds to a nursery near Valencia in Spain which they are growing
on for us. It now has about 30 or 40 species of cold hardy and cool
hardy palms, about 150,000 rare young palms, which no one else in
the world seems to be growing in commercial quantities. In a few
years time they will be available in good numbers and in reasonable
sizes. As we have discovered, often the only way to get these palms
in any numbers is to grow them yourself.
IMG: Do you obtain seeds from cultivated plants
or from the wild?
Martin: All our seeds are collected from the wild.
If anybody has any problem with the morality of collecting seeds
in the wild I must say that a lot of seeds in the wild dont
germinate, as the conditions are not right. A lot are also attacked
by insects or animals and so dont germinate. I have no qualms
about collecting seeds in the wild because that is often the only
way that they will germinate. Also it is often the only way to introduce
the palms into cultivation. I cant pretend that having people
grow Medemia argun or Nannorrhops ritchiana in England will save
them from extinction, but we do sell seeds around the world. A lot
of them will go on to produce perhaps quite a sizeable population
of these rare palms and it may have an effect on the future survival
of the species.
IMG: The Palm Centre has expanded considerably.
Tell me about it.
Martin: I opened up the nursery in Sheen in1989 having
bought the lease from a gentleman who was moving to a larger nursery
in nearby Ham. After a year I phoned him up and said could we meet,
and he told me afterwards that he thought I was going to say that
the Palm Centre is doing so badly would he like to take the lease
back. In fact, I was saying to him that the Palm Centre is doing
so well could I rent some space at his new nursery in Ham. So we
have actually had a presence here in Ham where the nursery is currently
situated for a number of years as we rented a part of the glasshouse.
Very recently we had the opportunity to take over the whole site,
about 5 acres.
At the old shop it was just me and one or two people. These days
it is over 20 people, 10 permanently on the payroll plus casuals,
and it has turned into quite a sizeable business. It has expanded
largely due in part to the effect of television programmes about
garden makeovers. People see palms and bamboos and other exotics
featured on these programmes and they want them. We are also wholesaling
palms now to other garden centres and the demand is increasing.
There is a general movement in the direction of exotic plants.
IMG: How long ago did you begin your garden, how
has it developed over the years and what are some of the more unusual
palms that you grow in it?
Martin: I began the garden at more or less the same
time as the Palm Centre. It is situated in south London in a sheltered
microclimate, since the north and east winds have to come over the
city before reaching that area. There are many rare and unusual
palms in it. Most of the Trachycarpus species are grown there, nanus,
martianus, oreophilus, perhaps the largest oreophilus outside of
Thailand. Lytocaryum weddellianum has been growing for three years
and is not affected by the cold despite its delicate appearance.
Cycas revoluta as well. Generally, Cycads dont do very well
in this country as they need a certain level of heat, and duration
of warm weather, before growing new fronds. When they do it is usually
too late in the season. I have lots of bamboos, also Ceroxylons,
and Guihaya argyrata, Chamaerops var. cerifera, several of the smaller
Chamaedorea palms which are under-used in this country. Both Chamaedorea
radicalis and Chamaedorea microspadix can recover from -8c. I am
also growing Rhapis multifida outdoors which is growing well. Rhapis
excelsa is the only commonly available Rhapis species in Britain,
yet there at least 8 species and several obscure ones. Arenga engleri
has also been undamaged by frost.
IMG: Trachycarpus fortunei and Chamaerops humilis
have been the main palms for over 150 years. What do you consider
will complement or supersede them in the 21st century?
Martin: Trachycarpus wagnerianus, and latisectus when
they become more widely available. Also Chamaerops cerifera will
become more popular than the green form although it is much slower
growing. Maybe some of the more exotic palms like Plectocomia himalayana
and Caryota Himalaya.
IMG: What do you consider to be your most important
contribution to the world of hardy palms?
I suppose it is opening the Palm Centre and endeavouring
to introduce new hardy palms into the country generally. I am constantly
striving to increase the range of hardy palms available to the British
and European public through a combination of seed collecting trips
abroad supplemented by buying in palms from overseas. Also, by selling
seeds to overseas nurseries for onward growing in other parts of
the world, these palm collecting trips reach a wider market. Sometimes
its an uphill battle. Customers are sometimes reluctant to
consider other palms and are resistant to change, preferring to
choose only the familiar, common palms like Trachycarpus and Chamaerops.
It can be so frustrating. I would like to change peoples perception
from seeing hardy palms as potted plants, to be stood outside for
the summer only, to seeing them as garden trees, an integral part
of the landscape. We are growing successfully many hardy palms that
are not thought of as hardy like Plectocomia himalayana. If you
give some palms minimum protection they grow very well like the
Chamaedoreas. Also experiment with different species. If you have
to protect them for a couple of weeks during the winter then fine.
It is well worth the special attention because they are then there
for the other 50 weeks of the year to enjoy. Instead of everybody
waiting for everyone else, it needs a few pioneers to actually plant
these palms and take a risk as there is always a risk involved.
I wish people would grow more Jubaeas. I know they are very expensive,
particularly reasonably sized ones. Everyone flocks to Cornwall
to see the large one in Torquay with 20 ft of trunk but dont
consider planting one themselves. If 99 more were planted 100 years
ago there would have been 100 to admire today instead of just the
one. There are lots more discoveries to be made. My mission is to
get palms planted outdoors!
IMG: Thank you for the interview. It was interesting
and I wish you well with the Palm Centre and future palm expeditions
27-09-21 - 12:47GMT
|| What's New?
|| New palm book
| Date: 24-05-2004
of Cultivated Palms
by Robert Lee Riffle, Paul Craft.
|| New: Issue 48
| Date: 24-05-2004
has been published in the Members Area.
|| Archive complete!
| Date: 03-12-2002
| All Chamaerops issues can now be found in the archive:
More than 350 articles are on-line!
|| Issues 13 to 16
| Date: 28-08-2002
| Chamaerops mags 13,
have been added to the members area. More than 250 articles are now online!
|| 42 as free pdf-file
| Date: 05-08-2002
Download! Chamaerops No. 42 can be downloaded for free to intruduce the new layout and size to
|| Issues 17 to 20
| Date: 23-07-2002
| Chamaerops mags 17,
have been added to the members area. Now 218 articles online!
|| Book List
| Date: 28-05-2001
a look at our brand new Book List edited by Carolyn Strudwick
|| New Book
| Date: 25-01-2001
by Mario Stähler
This german book tells you all about how to cultivate your palms in Central Europe. more...